Captain America is one of the greatest cultural icons in the world, since his very first appearance in Captain america comics # 1 in 1941. While he’s so well-known, some fans may not be aware that there are some pretty differences between the version of Captain America that appears in Marvel Comics and the one that was a big part of the MCU.
On the surface, the two versions are the same, with a young Steve Rogers volunteering to be a hero for his country and then being trapped in ice for years. But when fans dig deeper, they find differences big and small in Captain America’s story. Although it remains the same at the base, each version is unique to its medium.
ten He was only Bucky’s partner
Fans know that Bucky Barnes is one of Captain America’s best friends in the MCU. But that hasn’t always been the case in Marvel Comics. In their early adventures and for most of Marvel history, Bucky was primarily Steve Rogers’ teenage sidekick. They were partners and allies, but they didn’t grow together like they did in the MCU.
In the MCU, Bucky and Steve grew up in the same neighborhood and are much closer than the comic book versions ever were. The comedic duo have grown closer in recent years since Bucky’s resurrection as the Winter Soldier, but the backstory hasn’t changed.
9 He did not become a nomad
Although Captain America gives up his shield at the end of Captain America: Civil War, he never goes so far as to become Nomad, as he did in the comics. Steve Rogers’ disillusionment with the US government causes him to stop being Captain America and become a thug under the guise of Nomad for some issues between Captain America # 180 and # 184.
In his place, another Captain America walks and fights alongside Sam Wilson, but it’s not right at all. Steve Rogers quickly returns to the fold and takes up the torch.
8 He didn’t overthrow the president
Captain America has fought against the pillars of power in the MCU, but unlike the comics, he never toppled a sitting US president. This is what happened in “Secret Empire”, a shocking storyline that depicts some of the best Captain America comic numbers from the 1970s.
In the storyline, Captain America uncovers a massive government conspiracy that leads all the way to the White House with the President (who is never named or fully seen) being the masked figure behind the insidious plot to destroy freedom.
seven He didn’t die fighting Thanos
In the MCU, Captain America was one of the Avengers to survive The Snap. In the comics, that was also true, but he didn’t exactly outlive Thanos. In The Infinity Gauntlet ’90s miniseries that inspired the MCU, Thanos kills Captain America in their first battle.
Armed with the Infinity Gauntlet, Thanos is all-powerful. Yet it’s a shocking turn of events that shows just how high the stakes are. Captain America would sacrifice himself in the MCU, but he didn’t lose his life fighting to bring back all the people Thanos broke.
6 He was one of the invaders
An important part of Captain America’s comic book story that the MCU has yet to adapt is The Invaders. This is mainly because some of the WWII superhero team members like Namor and Human Torch were only available for the MCU recently.
Captain America joined forces with Human Torch and Namor during the war. Both were characters from Timely Comics in the 40s, later incorporated into the Marvel Comics continuity, as he was. With Marvel Studios now owning the rights to Namor and the Human Torch, it’s possible the invaders will appear in one form or another.
5 He was never a secret agent of the hydra
There are many important versions of Captain America in Marvel Comics that could still appear in the MCU. Whoever hasn’t yet is the version revealed to be a secret agent of Hydra dating back to WWII who then turned on America and overthrew the government.
This major twist of the Secret Empire The 2010s crossover was very controversial with fans and likely won’t inspire a direct adaptation in the MCU, but got a subtle reference in Avengers: Endgame when Captain America whispered, “Hail Hydra” to confuse Hydra’s agents.
4 He was trapped in ice for only 20 years
The essential elements of Captain America’s story are more or less in place in the MCU, including the fact that he’s frozen in ice. But in the comics, Captain America was only frozen for about 20 years. He was thawed in the early ’60s and joined the Avengers in Avengers # 4.
In the MCU, Captain America was frozen in ice from 1945 until now, 2011. It was necessary given the MCU’s timeline, but the passage of time was never really touched on in the comics outside of the storytelling. of alternate universes like Ultimate Comics.
3 He had a relationship with Sharon Carter
In the MCU, Captain America and Sharon Carter have a brief romantic moment, but ultimately her heart is with Peggy Carter. In Marvel Comics, Steve Rogers and Sharon Carter have a much more involved and sustained relationship.
Comic book fans know Sharon Carter is an agent of SHIELD and has been one of Captain America’s closest allies and friends throughout its comedic history. The MCU version went in very different directions, with Sharon being revealed as the Power Broker.
2 His shield is made of a different material
In the MCU, Captain America’s iconic shield is made of vibranium, the hardest substance known on Earth. In the comics, it’s made of adamantium, another incredibly durable metal. Comic book fans know that Wolverine’s claws and skeleton are coated with adamantium.
Although vibranium precedes adamantium in comics by three years (first mentioned in daredevil # 13 in 1966, with adamantium appearing in 1969) Captain America’s shield was later converted back to being original adamantium. The MCU chose vibranium because of the rights to Wolverine and adamantium being banned at the time.
1 Steve Rogers never returned to Peggy Carter
Steve Rogers and Peggy Carter are one of the MCU’s most enduring couples, with Steve returning to Peggy at the end of Avengers: Endgame. In Marvel Comics, the two were lovers, but their romance never carried the same weight as in the MCU.
Steve Rogers never went back in time to be with Peggy, and never had a hard time getting away from her as he did in the MCU. While Peggy has since grown into a more prominent figure in the comics, for many years she was mostly an afterthought.
NEXT: 20 Avengers Who Could Kill Thanos, Ranked By Likelihood
10 best Kingpin comics to read after watching Hawkeye
About the Author